Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Religion & Law Blogs -> Religion Clause

Religion & Law

: Religion Clause

Archbishop Speaks On U.S. Church-State Principles As Model For Other Countries

By Howard M. Friedman

Denver Catholic Archbishop Charles Chaput yesterday delivered an interesting keynote address (full text) at a Georgetown University conference on "Religion in American Politics: A Model for Other Countries?". Here are some excerpts from the talk which Chaput said emerged from his experience on the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom:

Principles that Americans find self-evident ? the dignity of the human person, the sanctity of conscience, the separation of political and sacred authority, the distinction between secular and religious law, the idea of a civil society pre-existing and distinct from the state ? are not widely shared elsewhere.... We need to ask ourselves why this is the case....

It's impossible to talk honestly about the American model of religious freedom without acknowledging that it is, to a significant degree, the product of Christian-influenced thought. Dropping this model on non-Christian cultures ? as our country learned from bitter experience in Iraq ? becomes a very dangerous exercise. One of the gravest mistakes of American policy in Iraq was to overestimate the appeal of Washington-style secularity, and to underestimate the power of religious faith in shaping culture and politics.....

What we see today is a repudiation of [the American] model by atheist regimes and secular ideologies, and also unfortunately by militant versions of some non-Christian religions. The global situation is made worse by the inaction of our own national leadership in promoting to the world one of America's greatest qualities: religious freedom.

This is regrettable because we urgently need an honest discussion on the relationship between Islam and the assumptions of the modern democratic state.... [W]e need to encourage an Islamic public theology that is both faithful to Muslim traditions and also open to liberal norms. Shari'a law is not a solution. Christians living under shari'a uniformly experience it as offensive, discriminatory and a grave violation of their human dignity.

A healthy distinction between the sacred and the secular, between religious law and civil law, is foundational to free societies. Christians, and especially Catholics, have learned the hard way that the marriage of Church and state rarely works. For one thing, religion usually ends up the loser, an ornament or house chaplain for Caesar. For another, all theocracies are utopian ? and every utopia ends up persecuting or murdering the dissenters who can't or won't pay allegiance to its claims of universal bliss.

Full post as published by Religion Clause on March 02, 2011 (boomark / email).