Public Defense

CT?s top death prosecutor in federal probe

By Gideon

I stumbled across this brief news item today, which could have monumental consequences for the death penalty in Connecticut, among other criminal justice issues. Waterbury’s chief prosecutor and former Commissioner of Public Safety John Connelly is apparently the subject of a Federal grand jury investigation, with allegations of improper consideration of his good friend, defense attorney Marty Minella’s clients, in exchange for gifts and vacations, swirling around the courthouse.

Connelly is known by most in the State as the prosecutor who put most of CT’s death row inmates on the row. The proportion of death row inmates from his jurisdiction have prompted valid calls for an examination of the application of the death penalty in Connecticut and allegations of racial and geographical disparity in sentencings and death penalty prosecutions. Connelly has a reputation for being a ruthlessly efficient prosecutor, who makes juries melt in his hands, and up to now, has been beyond reproach.

One can only begin to ponder the implications on the future of the death penalty and the criminal justice system as a whole if this story has any legs, if the federal probe turns into an indictment and a prosecution.

According to several sources who asked not to be identified, the feds are looking into whether Connelly’s ties with Atty. Martin Minnella have grown improperly close, and whether prosecutorial behavior in certain court cases can be connected – directly or indirectly – to gifts, vacations and other emoluments. The sources say federal investigators have seized records from both Minnella and Connelly, and that the list of potential witnesses is growing. Tom Carson, a spokesman at the U.S. Attorney’s Office in New Haven, said only, “We can neither confirm nor deny the existence of a grand jury investigation.”

Connelly has been on the job in Waterbury since the 1980s. Over 25 years, he has developed a reputation as a take-no-prisoners prosecutor who has, among other things, sought, and won, the death penalty in several big cases.

By last count, there were 6 inmates sent to death row by Connelly, of which two had their death sentences reversed. There are currently 9 on death row, excluding those two.

[It's really important for me to state this here: this is based on "anonymous sources" and it is about the very, very secretive federal grand jury. The extent of the investigation may be different, its focus may be different. But I've now heard this from several sources (yes, I have sources), who have other "anonymous sources", so it's pretty clear there's something going on, we just don't know exactly what.]

Full post as published by A Public Defender on August 10, 2010 (boomark / email).